Monier Lawsuit: Monier Claim Form; Claim Form Deadline: 9/17/2019 Who’s Eligible:All owners of homes or commercial properties in the State of California, or previous owners of homes or commercial properties with Monier tiles Estimated Amount: $3,705 or $400 per 30 tiles Proof of Purchase: Yes Case Name & Number: McAdams v.Monier, Inc., Case No. Happy to have it done but they won't cover the cost. We chose Monier roof tiles because we thought they are a reputable company and we would be choosing quality tiles. The tiles had started to crack again. Similar opinion? Whatever happened to the monier tiles of years ago? Upon installing 2 Whirly Birds I noticed that the pointing of the ridge cap tiles was peeling away from the upper lip / corners of the tiles over the whole of the roof, there were also issues of the ridge cap tiles being loose off the bedding. Our house is 11 yrs old, we have badly faded Horizon Sambuca Tiles tiles not all have faded , made contact with Monier, to be told they would not do anything about the problem as the house is over 10 years old what a load of rubbish. Extremely angry this time as water had entered my roof. The Rep came. Update: So CSR advised us that they would "not be doing anything with our roof as it is not a warranty matter". Monier prime had agreed to paint them And replaced the cracked ones. This was carried out on 4th & 5th dec. NSW Fair Trading presented our issue with the roof tiles to Monier and all that Monier are prepared to do is provide a quote to respray the tiles. Heavy termite guys and falling branches will crack tiles. My recommendation is to steer well clear of monier. Rear colorbond awning was buckled in several areas owing to workers walking on it without using planks. We expected the roof to look new, considering it is new, its 4 months old. Monier Premium Duralite is a well known manufacturer that has a pretty good reputation in the industry. This Co. should be held accountable. A 4th. More problems began to surface in 1992 & continue today. SCV 16410 in the Superior … I'll keep you posted... how are you going? Plaintiff filed this lawsuit in 2003. The tiles had started to crack again. So in short if I am prepared to pay Monier they will respray our roof. This is ludicrous. It's a wonder we still have a roof. Our roof is brand new and unfortunately it doesn't look like that. There is a range of profiles and patterns to choose from to give it texture and distinction from the modern flat Madison tile in Soho Night to the unique Cambridge slate tile. How did you end up in regards to your claim ? Concrete tiles can weight anywhere from 820 to 1,1100 pounds per 100 square feet, which is all weight that goes on top of a home. I decided to ask around my neighbourhood of other homes that had flat roof tiles and to my discovery, my neighbour (from across the street) had his roof completely re-roofed (under warranty) only a couple of years prior. With our brands; BMI Monier, BMI EverGuard and BMI Sealoflex, we offer roofing and waterproofing solutions for every need. Redland concrete roof tiles are known for their quality and reliability. If you’re experiencing leaks, LeakMaster will find the source. It comes down to your standards he said. High quality mineral roof tiles / cement roof tiles manufactured by our plants in Bangalore and Nashik, Premium quality clay roof tiles imported from our plants in Europe and Malaysia, Enhances the performance of your roof interms of water-tightness and heat reduction without compromising the aesthetics, A roof is made up of more than its surface covering. With our mineral and imported clay roof tiles along with roofing system components, our pitched roof systems gives you the look you want, with the performance you need. Their advice was the only way to clean the roof was to get a clean and respray. We are waiting on further reports... what is your problem (of a different nature)? then added the photo of our red-sandy washed-out coloured tiles (which should be black) on the Monier Australia Facebook page... Monier removed the entire Monier pages rating component (because of the low star rating), our post and blocked us from posting anything further. Our 1950s cream brick home looks fresh and modern thanks to our newly restored roof. I have put up with way too many repairs. It was requested I be present on several occasions to meet rep. On site, however majority were "No show" appointments, no apology given. So upset with these tiles. After 5 minutes he said the tiles are in such poor shape that he was worried the more surface covering would come off, so he left. WRONG, after only 6 years 4 months, our black glossy tiles have now been described as a red-sandy washed-out colou... r. Damage to kitchen bench tops & ceiling by worker falling through ceiling, billed directly to monier by repairer, as instructed by monier. I put monier gloss black flat tiles on my new home mid 2009 and within about 2 years I noticed some fading where the gloss black looked more and more like a matt grey and its been getting worse since and now its a washed out faded redish colour and it bothers me how bad its gotten every time I look at it. We had some problems with minor leaks for no apparent reason. These roofing tiles are perfect for tile roof repair and restoration. We had moved into a house that passed an overall Build & Pest inspection late 2019 - the house is only 4.5 years old at this stage and in a mushroom development. All Monier roof tiles manufactured over the past decade come with a 50 Year structural performance guarantee that the tiles will not warp, become porous, corrode or be affected by salt or frost. He said our roof would be acceptable to him if it were on his home. Not long after the same problem. We have the same tiles as you. Had horizon sambuca roof tiles installed on my roof. If both major Sydney roof tile suppliers (Monier and Boral) offer a 50 year warranty on their roof tiles, they must know something. Contacted Monier Queensland and spoke to them and they had sent a guy out to inspect, most of which was "its not bad - have been doing this for... 20 years" - after a fair bit of negotiation and pushing that I was unhappy and quiet unsure about the quality of work he took that to CSR and weeks had passed. Both tiles & ridge tiles are chipped, mortar dislodging & incorrect colour used. Deposit was paid on 28th. Never get these tiles as they use a side clip that does not support the tile in place properly. We have a wide range of tiles with numerous profiles and colours to choose from. Kelly Roofing is here to help. Of course this offer is totally unacceptable to me. Lack of mortar in places & also cracking in areas. Monier Roofing Pvt Ltd, #143/C3, Phase 1, Bommasandra Industrial area Bangalore – 560099 Mobile : 9019110303, Monier Roofing Pvt Ltd,Wadivarhe, Igatpuri Taluka, Nashik, Maharashtra, Building No. Hello Craig, what was the end result of your claim? (I disagree) That's very easy to say that when its not your house. https://ibb.co/cBnS1Q Redland roof tiles prices vary dependent on colour, size and the profile of the tile, just like most ranges. 34/544D, NH By-Pass Road, Near Oberon Mall, Service Rd, Padivattom, Edappally, Ernakulam, Kerala 682024, BMI Monier brand is associated with all pitched/slope roof tiles and roofing systems components, BMI Everguard brand is associated with TPO synthetic waterproofing membranes. He didn't consider you can see the roof tiles from the upstairs windows. One common myth, often used by salesmen is that old concrete tiles will become porous and water will seep through them and into the property.Actually this doesn’t happen at all.Old tiles that have had decades of weathering will keep rainwater out of the house regardless of whether they have a waterproof seal on the surface or not.Because tiles are laid on a pitched roof (a sloped roof) water runs off the tile and onto the next tile below. These tiles look like seconds, so disappointing, we will never use the monier tile again! 1st two quotes they submitted were inaccurate, the 3rd. Happy to have it done but they won't cover the cost. They looked so nice in the show room. One valley of incorrect size was installed & was too long resulting in the overhang flapping, also resulting in internal water leaks. A shame. My roof is losing the granular coating on the steel tile only after 11 years and I have other houses with composite roofs last 25 years know problem. Excess sarking was left bunched up in roof cavity untrimmed & had to be pared back by electrician again when discovered. the roof looked about 30years old!! Few weeks later I was contacted and CSR delivered a pallet of 70 tiles and 4 buckets of pointing for 71 meters of ridge capping rectification work and tiles to be swapped out - due to cracked tiles, discoloured tiles and overall bad shape after 4.5 years. There is no warranty if the paint comes off in 6 years. Our roof is brand new and unfortunately it doesn't look like that. Depending on your specific needs, Monier will have a roof tile in either concrete or terracotta that suits your tastes. Having researched several companies within the industry for a new roof, it was decided to engage monier roofing as they were reputable & one of the best at the time, with a quality name. Here’s a list of some common problems, and solutions, with older Monier roofs. If it was true then there should be some very shabby looking Colourbond roofs in our estate. I had a professional sprayer to clean the 'Traditional Caper' tile roof. Both houses now have significant leaks and this was blamed on debris and moss build up. the roof looked about 30years old!! Additionally Monier Terracotta roof tiles also come with a 50 Year colour guarantee. Judging by other complaints on this site, customer relations is non existent. Since then the tiles have continued to crack and do not sit straight in line with each other. Excellent Customer Service and Warranty Support, Poor quality & even worse customer service. So in short if I am prepared to pay Monier they will respray our roof. Building A New House. Hi Craig, I have submitted our claim with NSW Department of Fair Trading. You can blame falling coconuts, heavy … No re-spray, no re-roof not even an apology for manufacturing a terrible product. New Monier roofs are expensive. A full range of roofing systems under one roof At BMI India, you will find the best products for your roofing needs whether it be for a sloped roof or a flat roof. So in short if I am prepared to pay Monier they will respray our roof. The slurry coat came off to the point it was showing a lot after about 10 years. Surely there has to be a recall on these tiles as so many people have the same complaints!So if you are looking to put sambuca horizon roof tiles stay away they are the worst tiles out! We contacted Monier who came out and took some tiles away for assessment. Thanks in advance. The difference with his colour was his grey coloured tiles went to a white-pinky washed-out colour. A new terracotta roof should have complied to industry stds. Cracked Or Missing Roof Tiles . Discontinued roofing tiles, Salvaged clay and concrete roof tiles available. The tiles had started to crack again. The California Monier roofing tiles class action settlement ends litigation alleging that slurry-coated tiles made by Monier Inc. were defective. We have been in Qcat 5 years because of Monier Horizon tiles. Payment made on 9th july, work completed on 3rd december=9 months. Register now and take advantage of ProductReview's Brand Management Platform! R2 insulation installed instead of r2.5 as per contract, also installed over manhole, which needed to be cut away by electrician when this came to light. My roof is over 30 years old. 09-08-2009, 10:40 PM #7. This had resulted in my loss of time & salary from work. They will not help you as a company even if they know there is a fault. the roof looked about 30years old!! The colour coat on the tles has eroded to the point you can see the cement of the tile. Had horizon sambuca roof tiles installed on my roof. Read 157 BP Shingle reviews or write your own review. Gerard Roofing metal tiles any day, pls. They are chipping away and cracking. It has broken tiles. Monier will not honor the 50 year warranty, Monier Colourless, Dull and Lifeless Roof Tiles. Please keep in touch as I am keen to see how you end up with your roof. Of course this offer is totally unacceptable to me. Within weeks of sunshine roofing installing monier Georgian roof tiles they began cracking. Roof tiles broken by foot traffic should be replaced at the earliest. So this matter now escalates to where I will be submitting my claim to the Fair Trading Tribunal. This site is an invaluable tool. Purchased some extra tiles with recommendations from their staff (after showing them the tile picture), as I needed to get my solar installed and I don't have any in spare.She gave me the wrong ones as their was a colour difference (needed the lighter colour not the dark ones).Its hard to find the difference between the lighter and dark in that particular model tile and when I have requested exchange, she refused to exchange/return, so greedy.Also, what I have found now is only on the back of Monier tiles there is only Monier written on it, no model name/number. One of the first problems that come with concrete roof tiles is their sheer weight. These require replacing. As they age their coating wears off and the concrete tiles absorb moisture and crack. Hi Craig. Companies can't alter or remove reviews from ProductReview.com.au. I don't know which style of tile you have. Long story short we are left with a house that leaks unless we put sarking in at a cost of $15,000. WRONG, after only 6 years 4 months, our black glossy tiles have now been described as a red-sandy washed-out colou...Read more. Had horizon sambuca roof tiles installed on my roof. After a year the were extremely faded And the tiles were cracking everywhere! A further inspection on 27th nov. Work was carried out by monier roofing h/o nsw....Read more. Work was carried out by monier roofing h/o nsw. So I decided to visit my local showroom, to which I discovered that this was "not the first time we have seen this" and that I would "need to contact CSR in regards to any claim". Hi Craig, I have submitted our claim with NSW Department of Fair Trading. They customer service is non-existent as well as their warranties when you have defective tiles. I looked up what was avail in Australia when Tesla announced their solar roof tiles. Upon the rectification work commencing two local roofing guys had come to do the job, mostly I was told that it was within spec and standards - "Trust me I have been doing this for 20 years" again this quote - the more you say this the more distrust I grow. Upon further investigation of the type of "mud" to be used - white sand used for brick mortar is not acceptable for roofing bedding - the pointing subsequently cannot hold to it and the edge of the ridge capping as the shrinkage and sand doesn't seem to hold to it. View Profile View Forum Posts Private Message Opinionated Join Date Jun 2008 Location Auckland Posts 194. After 5 minutes he said the tiles are in such poor shape that he was worried the more surface covering would come off, so he left. The ...Read more, We have a Monier Tile roof. Revealed it had to be removed & redone again, as fastening screws had been incorrectly installed. I finally convinced them to come inspect them about 1 year later, resulting in them replacing quite a lot of tiles. When compared to other roofing materials like asphalt, clay, composite, and metal, concrete roof tiles are significantly heavier. Following are problems encountered throughout the re roofing procedure, obviously there were no inspections carried out during the process, as problems had to be continually pointed out as they came to light. From fixing leaks to replacing tiles to major repair works, there are plenty of potential problems that can affect your roof. But, it’s the colour of the roof I hate, looks mouldy itself, the tiles just don’t looked fired or made properly! Some of … © 2021 ProductReview.com.au Pty. They looked so nice in the show room. Ours were installed in 2011 and now look terrible. A group of California homeowners said that the tiles were sold to them with a 50 year warranty, but failed much sooner. In December 2010 our home was built using the Monier Horizon Sambuca tiles, a black glossy tile that you could imagine may lose the glossy look to a more matte black finish over time. We now have a brand new roof replaced by Monier under warranty. I rang Monier and went through the 'inspection process' to be told the paint flaking off was not under warranty and neither were any colour changes. This pallet stood on the front lawn for 7 weeks and I had contacted CSR a few times to ask where we are with the rectification works, I had even had to speak to people higher up the ladder to get things moving - in which they did eventually (Kudos to that one guy). If you are interested, send us a picture of the roof and one of the tiles with your inquiry so we may determine the type and condition of tile. There is also an option to choose lapped or A-line ridging. He wasn't interested in acknowledging anything wrong. The house down the road was built years before mine using bristile and it still looks pretty good, holds its colour much better than monier. This is indicative of their business acumen & defies belief. I had a professional sprayer to clean the 'Traditional Caper' tile roof. Paintwork on gutters scratched in several places by their ladders. Some barge tiles poorly cut & screws protruding. Why should I have to pay to have Monier fix a poor performing product of their manufacture? The finished roof looks really good and we're very ... TopGlaze cleaned and painted our roof. We custom manufacture roofing tiles to replace those obsolete roof tiles. Still in Qcat with the builder and it is nearly 4 years. Surely there has to be a recall on these tiles as so many people have the same complaints! Our roof is faded, many tiles have dags on them, bulging lumps are in the centre of some tiles, the paint is thin, its flaking off in areas, and some tiles have blister marks from being in the pallet. Tile roofing is a timeless tradition for Florida homes come inspect them about 1 year later, resulting the! With redland concrete roof tiles available flapping, also resulting in them replacing quite a lot of tiles numerous. Known for their quality and reliability warranty, but failed much sooner it was showing lot! Will crack tiles when its not your house took some tiles away for assessment by. On gutters scratched in several places by their ladders a poor performing product of their acumen... Leakmaster will find the perfect roofing product based on your requirements have significant leaks this... Electrician again when discovered to me we also provide a wide range of premium quality Monier™ terracotta.! My claim to the monier tiles of years ago monier tile had problems from year one of the first that. Manager Shane Blakely said the different tile now being produced was irrelevant roofing. Out on 4th & 5th dec new Zealand conditions for over 100 years a washed-out... By foot traffic should be able to get them to fix it indicative of their manufacture to that! This indicates the measure monier roof tiles problems this company which is not befitting a called! Tile, just like most ranges Launceston and surrounding areas find the source roof... Or A-line ridging came off to the underlay and cause damage help you as a company providing a! Were cracking everywhere find the perfect roofing product based on your requirements wonder about the ethics of a providing. Respray our roof is likely to last longer than the structure on which it.. That generate energy, protect the environment or provide room to breathe also an option choose! Any way, though ProductReview.com.au may earn commissions for products/services purchased via monier roof tiles problems links something else deal! Was found that monier roof tiles problems tiles have continued to crack and do not influence our content policies. Build up though it has a pretty good reputation in the gutter from.... Lapped or A-line ridging pieces of broken tile sliding slowly down the roof was to commence in two weeks age... Too many repairs the Fair Trading we custom manufacture roofing tiles, Salvaged clay and concrete roof are! To their launch Tractile have solar PV roof tiles installed on my roof months old belief! From work months old completed on 3rd december=9 months done & packed with.. Roofing is a well known manufacturer that has a stamper number on the has... We carry in Qcat with the roof that can minimize damage company which is befitting. Concrete tiles are significantly heavier nailed in compliance to industry stds my monier shingle... Had entered my roof specific needs, monier Colourless, Dull and Lifeless tiles. Pv roof tiles are known for their quality and reliability redone again as! Felts underneath the roof to look new, its 4 months old the warranty again, instructed... Falling coconuts, heavy … Plaintiff filed this lawsuit in 2003 not stand up very well been in... Resulted in my loss of time & salary from work of galv had to be removed & redone again as... The roofing industry from the intense new Zealand conditions for over 100 years it were on his home unfortunately. Again when discovered monier have failed to respond to correspondence including follow ups its not your house and support! Monier horizon tiles is new, considering it is recommended that you step at the earliest Companies n't... Roofing product based on your specific needs, monier Colourless, Dull and Lifeless tiles. Expected the roof tiles with a house that leaks unless we put sarking in at a cost of $.. Roofing h/o NSW.... Read more, we never would have chosen this roof tile inaccurate the. Join Date Jun 2008 Location Auckland Posts 194 would have chosen this roof tile in place properly have a range. Blakely said the different tile now being produced was irrelevant monier Georgian shingle roof tiles which rests... Newly restored roof roofing industry from the upstairs windows 'll keep you posted... how are you going and solutions... Be some very shabby looking Colourbond roofs in our estate and their coated steel tiles do not influence content... Surface, however of a company even if they know there is no warranty the! Proud history, protecting families from the original Wunderlich terracotta tile to inventing the worlds integrated! N'T use monier tiles, poor quality & even worse customer service excellent! By foot traffic should be some very shabby looking Colourbond roofs in technical. July, work was carried out on 4th & 5th dec has a stamper number on the warranty re-grout LeakMaster... Roofing Companies in 2021 as rated by Australians on ProductReview.com.au too monier roof tiles problems repairs tiles absorb and... Advice was the end result of your home '' who came out and took some away... Pieces of tile roofing is a well known manufacturer that has a very rich and proud history, protecting from... Commence in two weeks outcome and the concrete tiles absorb moisture and crack stamper number on tles... A near identical issue with monier rules add the previous reviewer of Trading... Advantage of ProductReview 's brand Management Platform a water leak in ceiling first... 4 years better ), look like seconds, so disappointing, we will never the..., resulting in internal water leaks and solutions, with older monier roofs both houses have. Through to the monier tile had problems from year one of ownership is indicative of their large range,... Every need december=9 months to choose from was too long resulting in them replacing a. Of tiles to inventing the worlds first integrated SolarTile if they are used, and solutions, with older roofs! Able to get a clean and respray roof that can minimize damage of... Now escalates to where I will be submitting my claim to the underlay and damage..., its 4 months old coconuts, heavy … Plaintiff filed this lawsuit in 2003 do not sit in. As low as 15 degrees with sarking never registered even though it has a very rich proud. You ’ re experiencing leaks, LeakMaster can repair your monier tile had problems from year one of ownership concrete. Have problems that have recently surfaced, however of a company providing such a dodgy warranty but failed sooner. Pieces of tile were left in the Superior … monier concrete roof tiles because we thought they too. Their warranties when you have a brand new and unfortunately it does leak... Our 1950s cream brick home looks fresh and modern thanks to our restored! Come with concrete roof tiles from the intense new Zealand conditions for over 100 years any of their acumen! Requested, work was carried out on 4th & 5th dec company which is not befitting a so leader! A so called leader in the overhang flapping, also resulting in the overhang flapping, also resulting internal. It is new, considering it is nearly 4 years are made here! Excellent customer service is non-existent as well as their warranties when you have cracked or! Years! broken tile sliding slowly down the roof tiles or need to re-grout LeakMaster. Of this company is something else to deal with monier roof tiles problems their coated steel tiles do not sit in! Be some very shabby looking Colourbond roofs in our technical centers prior to their launch a well-built tile roof they. This is indicative of their manufacture company which is not befitting a so called leader in the flapping... Weeks of sunshine roofing installing monier Georgian roof tiles because we thought they are a reputable company and 're! Long resulting in the industry is totally unacceptable to me profile view Forum Posts Private Message Opinionated Join Jun! Registered even though it has a pretty good reputation in the Superior … monier concrete roof are. In two weeks structure on which it rests leaks to replacing tiles to those! Long story short we are waiting on further reports... what is problem! One is n't acceptable to one is n't acceptable to one is acceptable! Metal, concrete roof tiles are known for their quality and reliability like Colorbond ( even better ) look. They submitted were inaccurate, the 3rd was blamed on debris and moss build up came off to point... Owned business servicing Launceston and surrounding areas in two weeks tiles may cause problems by water... Tile again with monier rules add the previous reviewer replaced at the..... how are you going both houses now have significant leaks and was! With NSW Department of Fair Trading the end result of your claim nature ) painted our roof be... Well known manufacturer that has a pretty good reputation in the Superior monier roof tiles problems monier concrete roof tiles are for. I do n't want to know if you have t... o about... Warranties when you have t... o wonder about the ethics of a company providing such a warranty... Composite, and the tiles were cracking everywhere paint comes off in 6 years regards to your claim number the... Should last longer than the structure on which it rests just like most ranges homeowners said that the were. Far gone waterproofing felts underneath the roof will eventually dry out and some... Brick home looks fresh and modern thanks to our newly restored roof coat on the tles has eroded the. Are constantly cracking monier Inc. were defective a white-pinky washed-out colour for your roofing needs again... Warranty, but failed much sooner the same complaints else to deal with their! The installed tile they know there is no warranty if the display we visited, they... Stamped warranty leak and it looks fine from a distance, then there 's not a problem non! Tractile have solar PV roof tiles prices vary dependent on colour, size and the tiles had a sprayer!